Are passkeys safer than passwords? Why it’s time to ditch passwords
Are passkeys safer than passwords? Yes, and for most sign-ins they are safer than any password plus a code. Are passkeys safe enough to switch everyone over tomorrow? Not quite. Account recovery, shared logins and older apps need a plan first.
The reason they hold up is simple. A passkey only works on the real website it was created for, so a perfect copy of the Microsoft 365 login page gets nothing from it. That matters because the most common way around ordinary MFA is a relay: the victim types a password and a six-digit code into a fake page, and the attacker passes both to the real site in real time.
Talk to an advisor
Ask about your own setup.
We ask what you’re trying to accomplish and tell you what we’d look at first. It costs nothing to talk, and no price comes up on this call.
Are passkeys safe compared with passwords and codes?
| Sign-in method | Can a fake login page steal it? | Other weak point |
|---|---|---|
| Password alone | Yes | Reused across sites and exposed in breaches |
| Password plus text or voice code | Yes, the code can be relayed | SIM swapping can redirect codes |
| Password plus app push with number matching | Yes, if a convincing caller talks someone into reading the number out | Push bombing, though number matching stops blind approvals |
| Passkey or FIDO2 security key | No, it only answers the real site | Recovery when a device is lost |
Microsoft now requires number matching on all Authenticator push notifications, which helps a lot. Our guide on how push bombing works and how to stop it covers that attack.
For our clients, admin accounts use phishing-resistant sign-in such as FIDO2 security keys or passkeys, and everyone else uses app approvals with number matching. Admin accounts can change everything else, so they get the strongest protection first.
Verizon’s 2026 Data Breach Investigations Report found that exploited software vulnerabilities have edged past stolen credentials as the top way attackers get in, for the first time in the report’s history. Stolen logins are still one of the easiest doors, and passkeys close it.
What is a passkey, and how does it work?
A passkey is a sign-in credential based on the FIDO standards (FIDO2 and WebAuthn). When you create one, your device makes two matching keys. The public key goes to the website or service. The private key stays on your device or in your credential manager and never leaves it.

When you sign in, the site sends a challenge, your device signs it with the private key, and the site checks the signature with the public key. You approve it with your normal screen lock: Face ID, a fingerprint, Windows Hello or a PIN. Your fingerprint or face data stays on the device and is never sent to the website. And because the site stores only your public key, a breach there leaves no password hash to crack or reuse elsewhere.
75%
of people surveyed have turned on a passkey for at least one account, according to the FIDO Alliance’s World Passkey Day 2026 research.
Synced vs device-bound passkeys
Synced passkeys are stored in a credential manager such as iCloud Keychain or Google Password Manager and copied across your devices, which makes them easy to recover after a lost phone. Device-bound passkeys live on one device or hardware security key and can’t be copied. Microsoft Authenticator passkeys, Entra passkeys on Windows and FIDO2 security keys fall in this group.
NIST’s current digital identity guidelines (SP 800-63B-4) accept syncable authenticators for most sign-ins but not for its highest assurance level, which requires keys that can’t be exported. In plain terms, device-bound keys belong on your admin and finance accounts.
What changed in Microsoft 365
Microsoft’s timeline:
- 01Since September 1, 2026, passkeys have been the default method in Microsoft Entra ID. Users enabled for SMS or voice codes were automatically enabled for passkeys and are prompted to register one.
- 02On February 1, 2027, Microsoft plans to retire its own telecom delivery of SMS and voice codes. Organizations that still want those methods will have to use one of Microsoft’s telecom partners.
- 03From February 1, 2027, users whose only sign-in method is SMS or voice must register a passkey before they can keep signing in, with no opt-out. These dates apply to Entra ID in the public cloud.
Registration prompts are already reaching staff in tenants that still allow text or voice codes. What you control is which passkey types you allow, which groups must use phishing-resistant sign-in, and whether people hear about it from you before the prompt appears. Our Microsoft 365 services include setting these policies up.
Drawbacks and how to handle them
Lost or replaced devices
If someone’s only passkey is on a phone that falls in a lake, they need a safe way back in. Register at least two methods per person, such as a phone passkey plus Windows Hello or a security key, and write down a recovery process that checks identity before anyone resets access. Help desk resets are a favorite target for social engineering.
Shared accounts
Passkeys are built for one person per account. Turn shared mailboxes and logins into delegated access or individual accounts wherever possible, and keep the few that remain in a business password manager with an audit trail.
Apps that only take passwords
Plenty of line-of-business apps, vendor portals and older systems still only accept passwords. Use long, unique passwords stored in a password manager there, with MFA wherever it’s offered. Our complete guide to passwords and authentication covers the rules worth following.
Personal phones
A synced passkey on an employee’s personal phone is tied to their personal Apple or Google account. Decide whether that is acceptable, or require device-bound passkeys in Microsoft Authenticator for work accounts. Our BYOD guide covers the wider personal-device question.
A rollout order that avoids a help desk mess
- Put device-bound passkeys or hardware security keys on every global admin and finance account first.
- Decide which passkey types you allow, and whether the rules differ by group.
- Pilot with a few people across different devices and roles, and note every question they ask.
- Tell staff before the prompts appear. A short email with screenshots heads off most calls.
- Require at least two methods per person and document how lost-device recovery works.
- Turn off text and voice codes gradually once people are registered, starting with your highest-risk users.
- Keep the password manager for everything that can’t use a passkey yet.
Phishing-resistant sign-in also gives you a strong answer when a cyber insurance carrier, auditor or client security questionnaire asks how you protect accounts that touch sensitive data. We fill out those insurance questionnaires for our clients as part of our cybersecurity services, and missing MFA is one of the gaps insurers commonly flag.
Microsoft’s passkey registration prompts started rolling out on September 1, 2026, and steering your staff now is easier than sorting out lockouts later. Book a 15-minute call and we’ll look at which sign-in methods your tenant allows today.
Frequently asked questions
What is a passkey?
A passkey is a sign-in credential based on the FIDO standards that takes the place of a password. Your device creates two matching keys: the public key goes to the website, and the private key stays on your device or in your credential manager. You approve each sign-in with your screen lock, such as Face ID, a fingerprint, Windows Hello or a PIN.
Are passkeys safer than MFA?
Passkeys are safer than MFA that uses text codes, one-time codes or app push approvals, because those can be relayed through a fake login page while a passkey only answers the real site. A passkey is itself a phishing-resistant form of MFA, combining something you have with your screen lock. Number matching on app approvals helps, but doesn’t stop every scam.
What happens if you lose the phone with your passkey?
Synced passkeys stored in iCloud Keychain or Google Password Manager come back when you sign in on a new device. Device-bound passkeys don’t, so you need another way in. Register at least two methods per person, such as a phone passkey plus Windows Hello or a security key, and use a recovery process that checks identity before resetting access.
Can passkeys be hacked?
A passkey can’t be phished by a fake site or leaked in a website breach, because the private key stays on your device and the site stores only a public key. The weak points are elsewhere: someone who unlocks your device, takes over the account that syncs your passkeys, or talks a help desk into resetting your access. Protect those with a strong screen lock and identity checks before resets.
How do you create a passkey?
Sign in to an account that supports passkeys and accept the prompt to create one, or add one from the account’s security settings. Your device makes the key pair and asks you to confirm with your screen lock. Microsoft now prompts Microsoft 365 work accounts to register a passkey, and your IT team decides which passkey types are allowed. Register at least two methods so a lost phone doesn’t lock you out.
Sources
- FIDO Alliance: Passkeys overview
- FIDO Alliance: World Passkey Day 2026 adoption research, May 2026
- Microsoft Security Blog: Passkeys are the default authentication method in Entra ID, July 2026
- Help Net Security: Microsoft Entra ID will auto-enable passkey profiles and synced passkeys, January 2026
- Microsoft Learn: How number matching works in MFA push notifications
- NIST SP 800-63B-4: Digital Identity Guidelines, Authentication, 2025
- Help Net Security: Verizon 2026 DBIR findings, May 2026
Next step
Let us handle this for you.
Email sign-ins watched, fake email rejected, staff phishing tests and a security operations center.
- 15 minutes
Tell us which question brought you here and how your office runs.
We’ll tell you how it applies to you and what we’d look at first.
If we’re not the right fit, we’ll say so.
